The technical report comprises 11 chapters, organized
into four parts. The report,
- discusses the principle areas of environmental management
related to the water sector;
- presents practical methodologies and approaches to
address the major challenges in each of the key areas;
- draws lessons and best practices information on topical
issues related to environmental sustainability of
water resources management for dissemination; and
- recommends specific actions for effectively integrating
environmental sustainability criteria in water policies,
for improving water resources project planning and
management decision making, and for strengthening
the capacities of water and environmental management
agencies.
Part 1, with four chapters, provides the overall context of
the report, which is to strive to achieve a sustainable balance
between the development of water resources for
beneficial uses and their protection.
Chapter 1 Environmental Sustainability in Water
Resources Management: A Conceptual Framework
presents the conceptual tools for defining and mainstreaming
environmental sustainability (in social, ecological
and economic terms) in water resources management
in the SADC region, and points to opportunities
to build upon the existing policy and institutional
reforms at both the national and regional levels.
Chapter 2 Water and the Economy provides the socioeconomic
and ecological context of the water sector in
the region, and describes the principle characteristics of
the water resources, the present and projected multi-sectoral
uses of water, and their implications to the region’s
economy.
Chapter 3 The Role and Importance of Aquatic
Ecosystems in Water Resources Management
describes the critical role of aquatic ecosystem structure
and function, presents the major aquatic ecosystems of
the region and discusses their importance, and describes
current initiatives in the region to understand and manage
aquatic ecosystems more effectively. The principal
threats to freshwater ecosystems are examined, including
the regulation of flow, water pollution, habitat destruction
and the introduction of alien species of fauna, as is the
threat and severity of species extinction.
Chapter 4 Valuing the Environment in Water
Resources Management focuses on a central issue in
the debate on the sustainable management of water
resources, and describes the methods for the valuation of
environmental damage and the economic trade-offs often
made in allocation decisions. It describes the economic
benefits of water use, the economic trade-offs involved in
allocation decisions, the main causes of aquatic ecosystem
degradation, and the valuation of environmental damage
using different methods representing the state of the art
in natural resource economics. It presents examples of
the impacts of environmental degradation on water supply,
and the different values of ecosystem services and
functions as well as the costs of their degradation. The
chapter recommends measures for accounting for environmental
degradation in the project decision-making and
highlights the principle economic instruments, supply
side and demand side measures, for regulating water use.
Part 2 also has four chapters, each focusing on particular
aspects of water resources management that impact on
the sustainability of the resource base. Part 2 contributes
to defining the key elements of environmental sustainability
in the water sector, and providing operational strategies
for achieving sustainable management of water
resources.
Chapter 5 Environmental Flows: Requirements and
Assessment discusses the single most difficult issue in
the environment/water management debate: that is, how
much water to allocate for downstream ecological purposes
when planning a major storage dam or abstraction
project for generating power, or for irrigation, municipal
supply or flood control. It draws from a rich array of
innovative works in progress being carried out in the
SADC region, including water policies in South Africa,
Zimbabwe and Tanzania as well as the Instream Flow
Requirement Study for the Lesotho Highlands Water
Project. The chapter starts with a description of the ecological
relevance of different kinds of flows and the purpose
of environmental flow assessment, and the effects of
regulation of rivers in the SADC region. The chapter
shows the linkage between environmental impact assessment
and environmental flow assessment, describes the
scope and details of an environmental flow assessment,
and reviews and summarizes the currently used methodologies
for defining environmental flow requirements.
The chapter shows implications for incorporating environmental
flow allocation principles into water policies and
the existing challenges facing SADC with respect to environmental
flow requirements.
Chapter 6 Water Quality Management and
Pollution Control addresses the water quality aspects of
water resources management, issues which have not
received the attention they deserve because of the misperception
that water pollution is not yet a serious problem
in the region. In fact it is becoming clear that pollution
is an important problem impacting public health and
that it also exacerbates water scarcity by diminishing beneficial
uses of water. The chapter describes the main
sources of pollution, both point and non-point sources,
summarizes the consequences of water quality degradation,
and its severity and extent. Existing technical and
institutional options for managing water quality and controlling
pollution are reviewed, and a range of recommendations
for strengthening water quality management in
the region are provided.
Chapter 7 Watershed Degradation and Management
links upstream actions (land use and management) with
downstream effects on water resources, emphasizing the
importance protecting source waters. The chapter discusses
the principal causes of land degradation, including
poor cultivation practices, overgrazing and deforestation,
and associated biophysical and economic consequences
which result from the impact of loss of top soil and vegetative
cover on runoff and infiltration rates, the impacts of
sediment transport and deposition on reducing the economic
life of storage structures and hydraulic efficiency of
the water conveyance and river channels, the effects of
turbidity on water supply and water treatment and on
coral reefs in the marine environment. The chapter
describes the extent and severity of watershed degradation
in the region, and summarizes a range of watershed
management strategies, guidelines and mechanisms
together with examples of successful watershed management.
These strategies include both structural (engineered
solutions) and non-structural measures (such as
soil conservation programs, land use planning, zoning,
etc.). The chapter presents case studies illustrating successful
institutional arrangements and community participation
(centralized authorities or community based) and
financing arrangements for watershed protection, including
incentives for participation in watershed protection,
cross subsidies, charges or levies for raw water use, and
makes policy recommendations.
Chapter 8 Aquatic Weeds and Their Control is a
comprehensive review of the growing problem of water
weeds and their control in the SADC region, and it evaluates
the physical, chemical, biological and integrated
methods for controlling water weeds. The chapter
reviews the origin, type and extent of water weed proliferation
in southern Africa. The five main types of water
weeds commonly occurring in the region are identified
and their characteristics discussed. The main causes and
consequences of the water weed problem are described,
including the principle factors that influence the growth
of the weeds. The chapter evaluates the different methods
(physical, chemical, biological and integrated) for
controlling water weeds, as well as the advantages and
disadvantages of the main control methods. Selected case
studies covering a variety of control strategies are discussed,
and the adoption of an integrated management
programme is recommended. Policy and capacity-building
recommendations are given.
Part 3 of the report, with two chapters, addresses the
mainstreaming of the environment in the water sector,
and provides guidance on the institutional structures and
processes which best support the use of the operational
tools described in Part 2. The critical role of ownership
and participation are presented as essential ingredients in
several successful community-based water resources management
programmes. The adequacy of existing planning
tools, water and environmental policies and institutional
arrangements for the effective integration of environmental
quality considerations is reviewed.
Chapter 9 Community-based Water Resources
Management focuses on the importance of communities
in water resources management, using specific case studies
to address a range of issues raised in earlier chapters.
The case studies include sustainable cultivation of dambos
(wetlands in Zimbabwe), irrigation management in
Tanzania, participatory control of water weeds (for example,
in the Kwazulu-Natal), provision of rural water supply
through sustainable groundwater schemes (e.g., in
Zimbabwe), and the protection and management of
watersheds (eg Umgeni Water). The cases highlight key
principles relating to beneficiary participation in the
design of water management projects and programmes.
Key design features and specific policy recommendations
are provided for institutionalising community based water
management practices.
Chapter 10 Policy, Legislative and Institutional
Framework reviews the environmental elements of
water resources management in existing national environmental
policies and national water policies and planning
instruments. The chapter also evaluates the adequacy of
existing planning and regulatory instruments, such as EIA,
for integrating environmental issues into water resources
planning and management. Specific case studies are used
to evaluate the effectiveness and weaknesses of the EIA
process and actions for strengthening the EIA process are
recommended. The chapter recommends the strengthening
of environmental management aspects of water policies,
calls for developing harmonized sector policies, and
improving coordination between sector agencies, and the
use of participatory instruments for underscoring the
importance of environmental stewardship as an element
of national water policy and strategy for water resources
management.
The final Part draws from and is a synthesis of all the
other chapters, defines a clear set of environmental sustainability
criteria for the water sector for the SADC region
and recommends specific measures for mainstreaming
environmental quality considerations in the water sector.
Chapter 11 A Framework for Mainstreaming the
Environment in Water Resources Management proposes
a number of priority areas for action by governments
and other stakeholders in southern Africa to
enhance sustainability in terms of water and environmental
management. The central message is to simultaneously
encourage the development of water resources
to meet the growing multiple demands, but at the same
time to recognize the limits of sustainable use and institute
appropriate, cost-effective measures for protecting
the resource base.
|